Four & Twenty Blackbirds baked in a salty honey pie.

A few months ago, back during the height of “pie season”, my mother sent me a link to Daily Candy that featured this pie. The name intrigued me: Salty honey pie. Sounded awesome. As far as I’m concerned salted anything is pretty delicious- salted caramel, salted chocolate, etc.

I know of this pie shop & the name is pretty awesome. Not only that, but the cover of the book is awesome too:

The Four & Twenty Blackbirds pie book.

So anyway, now that the holidays have wound down & I’m not on a baking schedule of specific traditional treats, I thought I’d make this salted honey pie & see how it is. See if it lives up to the idea of deliciousness that I (& everyone else) has in my head. I made it twice (this is the second one). The first one didn’t look that great because I used a larger pie plate than I should have for the sake of convenience, and the crust slid down into the filling. This one was ultimately the better-looking one, so aesthetically speaking it “won.” However both tasted fantastic.

Salty honey pie recipe from Four + Twenty Blackbirds pie shop.

I think it’s Jay’s new favorite pie.

And I am always, ALWAYS bad at pie crust. Always. I just can’t get it perfect, ever. Oh well.

Salty honey pie.

SALTY HONEY PIE (from Four & Twenty Blackbirds’s new cookbook)

For the 9-inch double crust:
  • 1 1/4 c. unbleached all-purpose flour
  • 1/2 tsp. kosher salt
  • 1 1/2 tsp. granulated sugar
  • 1/4 lb. (1 stick) cold, unsalted butter, cut into 1/2-inch pieces
  • 1/2 cup ice water
  • 2 tablespoons cider vinegar
  • 1/2 cup ice


  1. Stir the flour, salt, and sugar in a large bowl. Add the butter pieces and coat with the flour mixture using a bench scraper or spatula.
  2. With a pastry blender, cut the butter into the flour mixture, working quickly until mostly pea-size pieces of butter remain (a few larger pieces are okay; be careful not to overblend).
  3. Combine the water, cider vinegar, and ice in a bowl or large measuring cup.
  4. Sprinkle 2 tbsp. of the ice water mixture over the flour mixture, and mix and cut it in with a bench scraper or spatula until it is fully incorporated.
  5. Add more of the ice water mixture, 1 to 2 tbsp. at a time, using the bench scraper or your hands (or both) to mix until the dough comes together in a ball, with some dry bits remaining.
  6. Squeeze and pinch with your fingertips to bring the dough together, sprinkling dry bits with small drops of the ice water mixture, if necessary, to combine. Shape dough into a flat disc.
  7. Flour a flat surface, then roll out dough into a 12- to 13-inch circle. Carefully place dough in 9-inch pie pan, trim hanging edges, and crimp. Wrap pan in plastic and refrigerate for at least 1 hour, preferably overnight, to give crust time to mellow. (Wrapped tightly, the dough can be refrigerated for 3 days or frozen for 1 month.)

Salty honey pie!

For the filling:
  • 1/4 lb. (1 stick) unsalted butter, melted
  • 3/4 cup granulated sugar
  • 1 tablespoon white cornmeal
  • 1/2 teaspoon kosher salt
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla paste (Nielsen-Massey makes a readily available one)
  • 3/4 cup honey
  • 3 large eggs
  • 1/2 cup heavy cream
  • 2 teaspoons white vinegar
  • 1 to 2 teaspoons flake sea salt (like Maldon), for finishing


  1. Have ready the frozen or refrigerated pastry-lined 9-inch pie pan (yes you can use a frozen pie crust for this, just defrost it, put it in the pan & then refrigerate it or freeze it again).
  2. Position a rack in the center of the oven and preheat the oven to 375°.
  3. In a medium bowl, stir the melted butter, sugar, cornmeal, salt, and vanilla paste.
  4. Stir in the honey and the eggs one at a time, followed by the heavy cream and vinegar.
  5. Remove the pie shell from the refrigerator or freezer, place on a rimmed baking sheet, and strain the filling through a fine-mesh sieve directly into the pie shell (or strain it into a separate bowl and then pour it into the shell).
  6. Bake on the middle rack of the oven for 45-50 minutes, rotating 180 degrees when the edges start to set, 30-35 minutes through baking.
  7. The pie is finished when the edges are set and puffed up high and the center is no longer liquid but looks set like gelatin and is golden brown on top.
  8. Allow to cool completely on a wire rack, 2-3 hours.
  9. Sprinkle with flaky sea salt.
  10. Reheat or serve at room temperature. (The pie will keep for 4 days in the refrigerator or at room temperature for 2 days.)

Salty honey pie from the Four + Twenty Blackbirds pie book.

I used Maldon sea salt on top, and I’d suggest you be a little liberal with it. You want that saltiness to really come through. I know, I know, Maldon is $10.00 for a little over 2 cups of salt… but it’s WORTH it. And don’t go TOO crazy with it, you don’t want a thick layer of salt but you definitely want to taste it. It makes the pie!

You can also substitute 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla extract instead of the paste if you must. I’d recommend getting the vanilla paste, it’s a good thing to have. But if you decide to make this pie at- oh, say 3 a.m. & you have none… extract will be fine.

Four + Twenty Blackbirds' salty honey pie recipe.

Facebook Twitter Email


  1. Sela

    Agree w/Maldon being worth it. Never used vanilla paste – what is the difference in taste (if any) or is it just texture?

  2. Jay

    Do you have an online storefront with a PayPal link that I could use to order these on an auto-fill basis? I was thinking like one every other day automatically sent to my bedroom so I don’t even have to get out of bed… Thanks.


    not only is there life after kids… there is life after fifty, which i’m learning about even as i type… the good news here? it really does get better ‘n better ‘n better with each and every year (thanks to little things like workin’ out, good living/sex, and botox). thanks for the fun link! : )


    marly colucci disse:Obrigada por compartilhar com a gente sua historia!!!!Acho que vc abordou o assunto com muita sabedoria e clareza.Parabéns e que vc inspire muitos com sua escolha…..Eu já faço algumas coisinhas,não como carne desde criança e deixei laticínios e ovos qdo soube “de onde eles” vem, embora caia em tentação ainda com bolos e paõ de queijo!!! ):Adoro sua historias,seu jeito de dividir o conhecimento e suas receitas!!!!Muito obrigada, vc me encoraja a cair muito menos em tentação do que antigamente….


    Mda… După părerea ta, PNL ar fi fost la guvernare – prim-ministrul Ungureanu cică liberal, MeleÅŸcanu se dădea ÅŸi el liberal, dacă te forÅ£ezi puÅ£in mai găseÅŸti niÅŸte ”liberali”… Cu ce-s mai buni PDL-iÅŸtii ”hoÅ£i-comuniÅŸti” decât PSD-iÅŸtii?


    Ironically, some of the forefront defenders of free speech before 1973, in particular for Turkish authors, now are siding with the Turks, against Western sivilization.One even works to establish in Norway, an official Since they haven't gotten just there yet, they have still managed to establish a play financed by taxpayers, via Støre's department, praising Saladin as a hero. They even call it "the international Saladin days". Nothing less!And the persecuted Turkish authors..what happened to them? Not so interesting any longer?


    And today, realizing that military moral is at an all time low (Petreaus’ actions didn’t help) we are being told that Lurch John Kerry is being floated for Secretary of Defense and the lying Susan Rice for Secretary of State. Gee, I wonder if our military will shrink due to all those whose father’s fought in Southeast Asia, and remember John Kerry as no more than a traitor to his nation, deciding they can no longer support a military who has a traitor as their chief officer.Reply


    Spielkind, möchte ich hier nur kurz erwähnen, ist älter als ich. Aber Spaß hatten wir beim gemeinsamen Abwaschen/-trocken natürlich trotzdem. @Foodfreak:Gern – ich mag dieses Event gern, ich schaue dann immer mal wieder in Kochbücher rein, die ich sonst gerne vernachlässige, auch wenn ich dieses mal habe kochen lassen.Sind nicht eigentlich alle Cremesuppen glutenfrei, also die selbstgemachten?


    Hallo Sabine,schön, endlich mal ein Foto von dir zu sehen!Siehst noch genauso aus wie im Sommer in Pula.Äußerlich nicht verändert, aber innerlich bestimmt? Wünsche dir noch schöne Tage und eine gute Heimreise. Und einen leckeren Glühwein auf dem Weihnachtsmarkt.LG Gabi und Josef


    Why would any man in his right mind ever live in Massachusetts under these new rules? For that matter, why would any man in his right mind ever set foot in the Commonwealth? I’ve thought for a long time that there must be something in the water there that melts people’s brains. This just reinforces that opinion.BTW, I was born in Framingham, back when reason still ruled, or at least competed. (Early edge of the Boom.)


    Our lovely dog Ursa was named by my husband, Steve. He found her at 5 weeks of age hanging out on a county road in Wilton, NC. She looked like a little black bear, so she was named after Ursa Major, the bear constellation, And I do believe the name fit her perfect!


    Fantastic box! I love monochrome and monochrome with one makes for a really dramatic effect. The stamp fits the box just perfectly, great design! You are so right as the stamp is so intricate just adding the ribbon only, makes it look really classy!


    Glad u are finally back and well Mike………….. I have been sad and at a loss without your wonderful blog and previews. Anyway, that is going to be one hot podcast with those orange tights, and glad it is being filmed early!!!

  14. business health insurance

    Ne approfitto per farti i complimenti per la sezione ricette, le foto delle diverse fasi sono belle e tutto si presenta molto bene, buono e professionale. Serve maggior promozione, per rendere il tuo blog nazionale, se non internazionale!! baci LGS


    You are assuming that a few chavistas plus the opposition deputies of the NA are interested in declaring an absolute absence and having Diosdado Cabello in place until new elections….De Guatemala a Guatepeor?


    aslında 4650 dr3 modeli hala favorim çünkü crysis Warhead dışınfa 1280×1024 de aaxsız iyi sayılır, 4770 almak varken 5770/50 iÅŸime yaramaz pahalı hala ve dx11 oyun oynayacak olunca bekler 5830 alırım belkiama beklemeli ÅŸimdi hele nV gt300 için 5-6 ay varsa fiyat da düşmezse Açıkcası Sırf Dx11 için ve düşük Watt için "5770 in neyi var fazladan 4770 den" anlayamadım iÅŸime yaramayacak teknolojiyi ne yapayım


    Yeah, suffice it to say that I am going to get pounded. I have one primary goal: stay with the pack over the first major climb at 10 miles in. After that, do whatever I can. Riding smart is all I really want to achieve. Lots to learn.


    chocolat | (15:55) tu n’aimes pas quoi? babengayo zobattant mais ya solo oza zobattant pona paroles ezobima namunokonayo oyoya mabe lokola babouin eza ba insultes ponangai oza pe okotikala ZOBATTANT ezalikombo kitoko pona yo tala kaka !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!vrai kombo ebongi nabatu neti bino kiadieee, kiekiekieeeeeeee zobattant flash mais ozo flasher te zobattant.


    I have seen that today, more and more people are attracted to video cameras and the field of pictures. However, to be a photographer, you will need to first commit so much time deciding the exact model of photographic camera to buy in addition to moving from store to store just so you might buy the most economical camera of the brand you have decided to select. But it doesn’t end at this time there. You also have to think about whether you should buy a digital digital camera extended warranty. Thanks a lot for the good recommendations I received from your website.


    disse:Nice post. I was checking constantly this blog and I am impressed! Very helpful info particularly the last part I care for such info a lot. I was looking for this certain information for a long time. Thank you and good luck.




    Finally durban designers are getting a chance to show their talent in durban! The show was incredibly well organised and the media coverage was a new designer for the competition it has brought me a lot of positive responses and I am so greatful and hope that this show continues as it allows an amazing platform for designers to showcase upon.


    KIITTI JENGI!! Taas olette paljon mua fiksumpia. Mä olen ajatellut, että koska syön kalaa aika paljon, riittäisi toi D-vitamiinilisä, ehkä siis mietin asiaa uudelleen. Tähän aiheeseen palaan ehdottomasti uudessa postauksessa. Vetäisen nyt eka tän purkin tabut ja sitten taidan siirtyä toiseen merkkiin.. Ootte niin parhaita tyyppejä!!


    I ought to admit that this can be 1 wonderful insight. It surely gives a company the opportunity to get in on the ground floor and really take part in generating one thing particular and tailored to their needs.


    Correcteurs : En l’absence de virgules l’enserrant, Pénélope pourrait n’être qu’une des épouses dudit prétendant à la direction de l’UMP !Vous pinaillez là.son dernier grand meeting de campagne, auquel participaient :1) son épouse Pénélope2) plusieurs dizaines d’ex-ministres et de parlementairesLe “et” entre 1) et 2) me semble suffisant. Nul besoin de sortir une verge de quelque nature que ce soit. (Entre parenthèses, il me semble que la langue anglaise se passe plus facilement de virgules que la langue française. Une question de rythme peut-être.)


    May27 This is the suitable blog for anyone who wants to search out out about this topic. You realize a lot its virtually arduous to argue with you (not that I truly would want…HaHa). You positively put a brand new spin on a topic thats been written about for years. Nice stuff, just great!


    Norma,muito interessante o tema. Acho que sentir-se obrigada a cuidar de A ou B ainda que sejam os pais, não pode ,de forma alguma interferir na própria vida a ponto de não permitir o crescimento.Todos devem se moldar um pouco, contribuir… Quando se está, como eu, de fora, fica fácil falar, mas basta estar na situação e pronto, nos embananamos mesmo. E aqui, ajudas as pessoas,num belo trabalho! beijos,chica


    Jeg hÃ¥per virkelig at det er en aprilspøk min venn…Hvis ikke, sÃ¥ har jeg full respekt for ditt valg – vÃ¥r og sommer mÃ¥ nytes til fulle.Jeg kommer tilbake i morgen og sier takk for meg, velger Ã¥ tro hardt pÃ¥ 1. april :-)Nydelig bilde har du iallefall, og kos deg med helgen Petunia!


    Do you know that Christianity is correct? The world around us reveals that G-d DOES exist, and the historical evidence reveals that Jesus Christ really did come to this earth and there is overwhelming evidence that Jesus Christ really did physically rise from the dead. Jesus is coming again and the signs of the end times that were foretold in the Bible are coming to pass.


    Oui enfin les musées gratuits, c’ets une bien jolie formule, mais en vérité, ça ne concerne que les 50 musées nationaux. Donc grosse blague, on paye encore plein tarif au musée des arts premiers par exemple …Et dans tant d’autres. (Et puis attention, ça ne concerne que les 18-25 ans. Et moi n’en ayant que 17, je n’y ai pas droit, ni d’ailleurs aux réductions étudiants … )


    írt! ( Ősz van … stb.) Ja !- fogalmam nincs, mitÅ‘l "javult meg a rendszer! " – ( értsd : nem mindegyik…) – ( "csak" a telefon meg a net…) **********************************Más :" A virág nevetett, a fasírt ! ) bár ezt "fÅ‘zés" témánál szoktam "felidézni!" – értelmezése : öntevékenyen ! *********************************


    Con mi unicornio rosa invisible no te metas. Estoy muy ofendido.Ya, en serio. Me interesa el reto paranormal. Puedo demostrar ante las cámaras y lo que sea mis dos poderes: dormir en cualquier sitio y orinar con la puerta abierta. Pero 20000 no me alcanzan para arreglar mis problemas así que quiero al menos una casa.Saludos desde Toluca, la capital nacional del aburrimiento.


    I and also my pals appeared to be checking out the exceptional solutions located on your web page whilst immediately got a horrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to you for those techniques. My guys ended up for that reason stimulated to see them and have in effect surely been taking advantage of them. Thanks for genuinely considerably kind and also for obtaining such extraordinary data millions of individuals are truly wanting to be informed on. My sincere apologies for not saying thanks to you earlier.

  34. cheap insurance

    What amazing pictures of a truly awe inspiring place. I love the colors and textures of the rock building facades. The theatre reminds me of some I saw in Greece, but not as old, and not that amazing rose color. What a fabulous trip and thank you for sharing it.P.S. I made your peach and feta salad with the lavender dressing and it was just divine.


    North Korea wanted money, it could make some minor concessions on nuclear weapons. Then America and South Korea would shower it with money.The poverty and starvation that North Korea is experiencing are the result of its faith. Faith leads it to suppress and starve its people, following the traditions of Mao, Stalin, and Pol Pot. Faith leads it to fight its Israeli enemy.Iran, Venezuela, and North Korea don’t have the foggiest idea that they have no tangible quarrel with Israel.


    mówi:Za dziś do tej pory zapłaciłbym sobie naprawdę mało.Ale zauważyłem w tym wpisie coś za co zapłacę sobie więcej.Na 12 wpisów tylko 3 mają ustawione grawatary.Zabiorę się do pracy i zrobię specjalne łatwe szkolenie z tego tematu.


    I was just seeking these records for a time. After 6 hours of continuous Googleing, at last I acquired it inside your site. I question what’s having less Google method that will not rank this sort of informative internet sites in the surface of the list. Usually the very best web internet sites are brimming with garbage.


    Ah! ta eles estao certo entao?Fumar drogas la pode? querem a policia longe pra fumar, porque nao pedem pra sair e deixem pessoas com interesse em estudar na vagas deles?Destruir o bem publico pode tambem? entao vc, com todo respeito, é um bobão que paga (porque isso sai do seu do meu bolso) pra eles quebrarem.


    Absolutely. And then you’ve got what the character expects is going to happen. The viewer or readers expectations. Which are also mixed in with the expectations that a given genre creates. I don’t understands how all of this fits together,but I expect I will.


    deux iPad ou deux tablettes ? En tout cas, il aurait pu dire qu’il en gardait une pour lui et qu’il t’offrait l’autre… (la galanterie se perd, ma bonne dame !)Et tu crois qu’il me donnerait lui aussi son avis pour mon mémoire ?


    I absolutely agree with you Pamela, I’m not sure if you could tell in the pictures but the dogs had some distance between them, we were also keeping them moving so as not to focus on each other. Thanks for asking for a follow-up, I did answer it in tomorrow’s post.


    Mm, mmm, mm!Little Hussein ObamaHe said all Libs must lend a handAnd march behind a Democrat bandMmm, mmm, mm!Little Hussein ObamaHe said we must be queer todayDemocrat means you are GAYMmm, mmm, mm!Little Hussein ObamaHe said that we must take a standTo make sure Affirmative Action gets a chanceMmm, mmm, mm!Little Hussein ObamaHe said red, yellow, black or whiteAll are equally stupid in his sightMmm, mmm, mm!Little Hussein ObamaNO !Mmm, mmm, mmLittle Hussein Obama


    VIVA A CORRUPÇÃO..Há 30 anos atrás, os corruptos tinha 7 campeonatos, enquanto o Sporting tinha 16. Hoje, os corruptos tem 26 campeonatos, enquanto o Sporting tem 18. Acho que não é preciso dizer mais nada.VIVA A ROUBALHEIRA …


    Hi Matt, Ay-up no longer have a UK distributor and now ship everything from Australia. So you need to add Duty, admin & shipping to all orders and that is about £50 on that kit. More on the adventure one.I do like the convenience of the Maxx-D so that is my favourite at the moment. I will wait until the end of the month.bestSteven


    Oh dear it seems as if your internet site Going Home Posted Stitches consumed my 1st remark it is rather extensive we believe We’ll merely sum it up the things i submitted and state, I really relishing your site. I as properly am an ambitious blog writer but I’m still a new comer towards the complete thing. Do you possess any kind of tips and hints regarding inexperienced bloggers! I truly truly enjoy it… In addition did you hear Tunisia incredible announcement… Regards Flash Site Builder


    Fetelor este greu sa fi admisa in cercurile societatii cu “rusinea” de a fi virgina la 20 de ani, dar nu uitati ca dragostea lui Dumnezeu este nespus de mare si conteaza cel mai mult. Si apoi puteti sti ca un baiat serios nu cauta una care a mai avut pe cineva, chiar daca el nu a fost asa de corect, tot o fata serioasa cauta … nu-i asa baietilor?


    mi è arrivato un anno fa via sms e oggi via mail.. io di solito rispondo a chi mi invia le catene di informarsi prima di spedirle e mando il link relativo. di olito funziona. grazie a paolo.


    binza | (23:30) Wana eza chorale ya bana ya bishop. Na suka balobaki eloko moko très important, balobaki eza fête te mais eza ndenge bishop lungonzo abandaki kolinga soki aza ko prêcher il faut chorale ebeta ndenge wana na ambiance


    OK 1st take a very good look at your self. What do you like what do you not like so considerably. Function on that which you do not like. But do not listen to other people their opinions do not matter only yours does. Function on having the attitude that this is who you’re and if they don’t like it they can go to hell.


    Economy of scale definitely exists when it comes to gov’t services. Take a look at CT. Taxes much lower than NJ, Westchester and Long Island. The reason is that the towns are bigger, schools districts are bigger, police and fire departments are bigger. Probably the same number of teachers in the classroom, police on the beat, but significantly fewer Vice Superintendents of Schools and Asst Chiefs of Police making $200k+ along with their staffs each making $80k+ with full pensions and benefits for life.


    re:Raising GSE limitsIn my opinion, this is how Congress plans to bail out the banks. By raising the limits, the banks can get all of the problem loans off of their books and into the GSE portfolios. When the GSE’s are overwhelmed with losses, Congress will bail them out, thereby saving the banks. By the time they are bailed out, everyone will have forgotten who was really saved by this.


    dit :Salut David,En tout cas, bravo pour ton installation !Je vois qu’elle à finalement bien tenue le coup.Maintenant tu pourras dormir sur tes deux oreilles, lorsque la prochaine tempête arrivera…HI Bien amicalementFred, F5OZK


    Juu Nutrix on luettu ja todella tykkään ajatuksesta, että hommat tehdään ennemminkin vapauden ja ilon kautta kuin kontorolloimalla ja väkisin, suu irvessä. Marketissa koriin tarttuu ihan laadukkaita vaihtoehtoja. Lähinnä kaipaisi vinkkejä siihen ns. henkiseen ajatusmaailman muutokseen, että miten hommia lähestytään ennemminkin sen vapauden kautta…Vanhat toiminta- ja ajatusmallit kuitenkin istuu aika lujassa ja helposti homma menee turhan ryppyotsaiseksi kontrolloimiseksi


    […] I men­tioned in an ear­lier post, I’ve been sav­ing the tapes from my Dys­pha­gia Series, the ones that I use to paint one work on top of another. I’ve assem­bled them into this […]


    I just now wanted to thank you yet again for this amazing blog you have designed here. It can be full of ideas for those who are genuinely interested in this subject, specifically this very post. You really are all really sweet in addition to thoughtful of others plus reading your website posts is a superb delight to me. And what a generous gift! Mary and I will certainly have excitement making use of your recommendations in what we need to do in the future. Our collection of ideas is a mile long which means your tips will definitely be put to beneficial use.


    Boa tarde doutor .Estou com uma grande dúvida .Meu dente ciso esquerdo superior eata doendo muito .Alem disso,está sangrando e com mau cheiro, parece que esta enflamado,nao sei ao certo.Tenho medo de ter que operar, infelizmente tenho que eaperar a boa vontade do sus abrir vaga pra eu consultar.Amamento e gostaria de saber se existe algo que posso fazer em casa ate a vaga sair?obrigado .


    hello, thank you for your blog. it is very encoutraging. I am at the beginning of my infertility journey. am 33 and ttc for 2 years. I just started temping and noticed that my temp does not spike till 4 days after my LH surge pee stick result? Is that bad? do you put much stock in temping?thanks!!


    I focus on the importance of the recognition moment – taking the time to specifically, frequently acknowledge and appreciate someone for their behaviors and actions that have reflected the company values in contribution to


    Oh! I love this! and it indeed sounds very useful for characters’ names. I sometimes use Google and see what some sites can come up with but this one looks GREAT! Thanks for sharing, Katy! I also use some other sites to know which names were popular in 16th century France but that has to do with my WiP

Post a comment

You may use the following HTML:
<a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <s> <strike> <strong>